Awards
2008

- This Is How It Goes
- Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role/Drama: Scott McLean, Boulder Daily Camera Eye Awards

- The Gin Game
- Best Actor in a Wry Comedy: Jim Hunt, Westword Best Of Denver 2008 Awards
2007
Best Year by a Company: Paragon Theatre, Denver Post Ovation Awards

- The Night Heron
- Best Actor, Drama: Michael Stricker, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Supporting Actress, Drama: Mare Trevathan, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Supporting Actress, Drama: Mare Trevathan, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Supporting Actor, Drama: Jarrad Holbrook, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Lighting Design: Jacob Welch, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards

- Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
- Best Drama: Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Production, Drama: Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- #2 Best Production of 2007: Rocky Mountain News Rocky Top Ten
- Best Director, Drama: Warren Sherrill, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Actress, Drama: Martha Harmon Pardee, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Actor, Drama: Sam Gregory, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Actress, Drama: Martha Harmon Pardee, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Actor, Drama: Sam Gregory, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Supporting Actress, Drama: Barbra Andrews, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Play: Barbra Andrews, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards
- Outstanding Scenic Design: David Lafont, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards
- Oustanding Direction of a Play: Warren Sherrill, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards

- Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune
- Outstanding Production: Paragon Theatre, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards
- #4 Best Production of 2007: Rocky Mountain News Top Ten
- Outstanding Actor: Tom Borrillo, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards
- Outstanding Actress: Emily Paton Davies, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards
2006

- Sailor's Song
- Most Auspicious Debut by an Actor: Jeremy Make, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Scenic Design: David Lafont, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Lighting Design: Jacob Welch, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards

- The Caretaker
- Best Theatre Production, Westword Best of Denver 2007 Awards
- Best Supporting Actor, Drama: Warren Sherrill, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Actor, Drama: Warren Sherrill, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Supporting Actor, Drama: Jim Hunt, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Actor, Drama Nominee: Jim Hunt, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Lighting Nominee: Jacob Welch, Denver Post Ovation Awards

- Hedda Gabler
- Outstanding Scenic Design: Paragon Theatre, Colorado Theatre Guild Henry Awards
- Best Production of a Play, Drama: Paragon Theatre, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Director, Drama: Warren Sherrill, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Actress, Drama: Barbra Andrews, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Actress, Drama Nominee: Barbra Andrews, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Supporting Actor in a Drama: Josh Hartwell, Westword Best of Denver 2007 Awards
2005

- Buicks
- Best Actor: David Harms, Colorado Backstage Spotlight Awards
- Best Supporting Actor: Ken Witt, Colorado Backstage Spotlight Awards

- The Mercy Seat
- Best Portrayal of Human Nastiness: Paragon Theatre, Westword Best of Denver
- Best Actor: Michael Stricker, Colorado Backstage Spotlight Awards
- Best Actor-Honorable Mention: Michael Stricker, Boulder Daily Camera Best of 2005
- Best Actress, Drama Nominee: Martha Harmon Pardee, Denver Post Ovation Awards

- Misery
- Best Lighting Design: Melissa Strasser, Colorado Backstage Spotlight Awards
- Best Sound Design: Michael Andrew Doherty, Colorado Backstage Spotlight Awards
2004

- Look Back In Anger
- Best Actor: Michael Stricker, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Drama, Nominee: Paragon Theatre, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Actor, Drama Nominee: Michael Stricker, Denver Post Ovation Awards
- Best Actor, Drama Nominee: Michael Stricker, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Supporting Actor, Drama Nominee: Warren Sherrill, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards
- Best Supporting Actress, Drama Nominee: Kate Avallone, Outfront Magazine Marlowe Awards

- Emily Paton Davies
- Top Actress: Emily Paton Davies, Rocky Mountain News Top of the Rockies
- Best Year By An Actress, Nominee: Emily Paton Davies, Denver Post Ovation Awards
2003

- The Book of Liz
- Best Supporting Actress, Comedy Nominee: Emily Paton Davies, Denver Post Ovation Awards

- Vieux Carre
- Best Supporting Actor, Drama Nominee: Garret Glass, Denver Post Ovation Awards
2002

- Mojo
- Best Supporting Actor, Drama Nominee: Michael Stricker, Denver Post Ovation Awards
2001

- Moon For The Misbegotten
- Best Actress, Drama Nominee: Lisa Rucker, Colorado Theatre Guild Denver Drama Critics' Awards